Where was lise meitner born
Lise Meitner
Austrian-Swedish nuclear physicist (–)
Lise Meitner (, LEE-zə MYTE-nər; German:[ˈliːzəˈmaɪtnɐ]ⓘ; born Elise Meitner, 7 November – 27 October ) was an Austrian-Swedish nuclear physicist who was instrumental in the discovery of nuclear fission.
Completing her doctoral research in , Meitner became the second woman from the University of Vienna to earn a doctorate in physics. She spent much of her scientific career in Berlin, where she was a physics professor and a department head at the Kaiser Wilhelm Institute for Chemistry. She was the first woman to become a full professor of physics in Germany.
She lost her positions in because of the anti-Jewish Nuremberg Laws of Nazi Germany, and the Anschluss resulted in the loss of her Austrian citizenship. On 13–14 July , she fled to the Netherlands with the help of Dirk Coster. She lived in Stockholm for many years, ultimately becoming a Swedish citizen in , but relocated to Britain in the s to be with family members.
In mid, chemists Otto Hahn and Fritz Strassmann at the Kaiser Wilhelm Institute for Chemistry demonstrated that isotopes of barium could be formed by neutron bombardment of uranium. Meitner was informed of their findings by Hahn, and in late December, with her nephew, fellow physicist Otto Robert Frisch, she worked out the physics of this process by correctly interpreting Hahn and Strassmann's experimental data.
On 13 January , Frisch replicated the process Hahn and Strassmann had observed. In Meitner and Frisch's report in the February issue of Nature, they gave the process the name "fission". The discovery of nuclear fission led to the development of atomic bombs and nuclear reactors during World War II.
Meitner did not share the Nobel Prize in Chemistry for nuclear fission, which was awarded to her long-time collaborator Otto Hahn.
Several scientists and journalists have called her exclusion "unjust". According to the Nobel Prize archive, she was nominated 19 times for the Nobel Prize in Chemistry between and , and 30 times for the Nobel Prize in Physics between and Despite not having been awarded the Nobel Prize, Meitner was invited to attend the Lindau Nobel Laureate Meeting in She received many other honours, including the posthumous naming of element meitnerium in Meitner was praised by Albert Einstein as the "German Marie Curie."[1]
Early years
Elise Meitner was born on 7 November into a Jewish upper-middle-class family at the family home in 27 Kaiser Josefstraße in the Leopoldstadt district of Vienna, the third of eight children of chess master Philipp Meitner and his wife Hedwig.
The birth register of Vienna's Jewish community lists her as being born on 17 November , but all other documents list her date of birth as 7 November, which is what she used. Her father was one of the first Jewish lawyers admitted to practice in Austria.[1] She had two older siblings, Gisela and Auguste (Gusti), and four younger: Moriz (Fritz), Carola (Lola), Frida and Walter; all ultimately pursued an advanced education.
Her father was a freethinker, and she was brought up as such.[1] As an adult, she converted to Christianity, following Lutheranism, and was baptised in ;[4] her sisters Gisela and Lola converted to Catholicism that same year. She also adopted the shortened name "Lise".
Education
Meitner's interest in science began when she was eight, when she kept a notebook of her scientific research under her pillow.
She was drawn to mathematics and science, and studied the colours of an oil slick, thin films, and reflected light. The only career available to women was teaching, so she attended a high school for girls where she trained as a French teacher.
Biography template for professionals: Loftin's Learning Emporium. Buy licenses to share. School counseling. PreK ELA.
As well as French, her education included bookkeeping, arithmetic, history, geography, science and gymnastics. She completed high school in Women were not allowed to attend public institutions of higher education in Vienna until , but when this restriction was lifted, the requirement for a gymnasium education was waived and women only needed to pass the matura, the secondary school leaving qualification required for university entrance.
Her sister Gisela passed the matura and entered medical school in Meitner began taking private lessons with two other young women in , cramming the missing years of secondary education into two. Physics was taught by Arthur Szarvasy. In July , they sat an external matura examination at the Akademisches Gymnasium.
Four out of the fourteen women passed, including Meitner and Henriette Boltzmann, the daughter of physicist Ludwig Boltzmann.
Research, work and academia
University of Vienna
Meitner entered the University of Vienna in October She was particularly inspired by Ludwig Boltzmann and often spoke with enthusiasm about his lectures.
Her dissertation was supervised by Franz Exner and his assistant Hans Benndorf. Her thesis, titled Prüfung einer Formel Maxwells ("Examination of a Maxwell Equation"), was submitted on 20 November and approved on 28 November. She passed an oral exam from Exner and Boltzmann on 19 December, and was awarded her doctorate on 1 February She became the second woman to earn a doctoral degree in physics at the University of Vienna, after Olga Steindler who had received her degree in ; the third was Selma Freud, who worked in the same laboratory as Meitner, and received hers in Meitner's thesis was published as Wärmeleitung in inhomogenen Körpern ("Thermal Conduction in Inhomogeneous Bodies") on 22 February [15]
Paul Ehrenfest asked her to investigate an article on optics by Lord Rayleigh detailing an experiment that produced results Rayleigh had been unable to explain.
She was able to explain the results, and also made predictions based on her explanation, which she then verified experimentally, demonstrating her ability to carry out independent and unsupervised research. She published the results in her report on "Some Conclusions Derived from the Fresnel Reflection Formula".[17] In , while engaged in this research, Meitner was introduced by Stefan Meyer to radioactivity, then a very new field of study.
She started with alpha particles. In her experiments with collimators and metal foil, she found that scattering in a beam of alpha particles increased with the mass of the metal atoms. She submitted her findings to the Physikalische Zeitschrift on 29 June This was one of the experiments that led Ernest Rutherford to predict the nuclear atom.[18]
Friedrich Wilhelm University
Encouraged and backed by her father's financial support, Meitner entered the Friedrich Wilhelm University in Berlin, where the renowned physicist Max Planck taught.
Planck invited her to his home, and allowed her to attend his lectures. This was an unusual gesture by Planck, who was on record as opposing the admission of women to universities in general, but apparently recognised Meitner as an exception. She became friends with Planck's twin daughters Emma and Grete, who were born in , and shared Meitner's love of music.[21]
Attending Planck's lectures did not take up all her time, and Meitner approached Heinrich Rubens, the head of the experimental physics institute, about doing some research.
Rubens said that he would be happy for her to work in his laboratory. He also added that Otto Hahn at the chemistry institute was looking for a physicist to collaborate with. A few minutes later she was introduced to Hahn. He had studied radioactive substances under William Ramsay and Ernest Rutherford, and was already credited with the discovery of what were then thought to be several new radioactive elements.[a] Hahn was the same age as Meitner, and she noted his informal and approachable manner.
In Montreal, Hahn had become accustomed to collaboration with physicists—including at least one woman, Harriet Brooks.
The head of the chemistry institute, Emil Fischer, placed a former woodworking shop (Holzwerkstatt) at Hahn's disposal in the basement to use as a laboratory. Hahn equipped it with electroscopes to measure alpha and beta particles and gamma rays.
It was not possible to conduct research in the wood shop, but Alfred Stock, the head of the inorganic chemistry department, let Hahn use a space in one of his two private laboratories. Like Meitner, Hahn was unpaid, and lived off an allowance from his father, although somewhat larger than hers. He completed his habilitation in early , and became a Privatdozent.
Most of the organic chemists at the chemistry institute did not regard Hahn's work—detecting minute traces of isotopes too small to see, weigh or smell through their radioactivity—as real chemistry. One department head remarked that "it is incredible what one gets to be a Privatdozent these days!"
The arrangement was difficult for Meitner at first.
Women were not yet admitted to universities in the German state of the Kingdom of Prussia, which included Berlin. Meitner was allowed to work in the wood shop, which had its own external entrance, but she could not enter the rest of the institute, including Hahn's laboratory space upstairs. If she wanted to go to the toilet, she had to use one at the restaurant down the street.
The following year, women were admitted to Prussian universities, and Fischer lifted the restrictions, and had women's toilets installed in the building. Not all the chemists were happy about this. The Institute of Physics was more accepting, and she became friends with the physicists there, including Otto von Baeyer&#;[de], James Franck, Gustav Hertz, Robert Pohl, Max Planck, Peter Pringsheim&#;[de] and Wilhelm Westphal.
During the first years Meitner worked with Hahn, they co-authored nine papers: three in and six in Together with Hahn, she discovered and developed a physical separation method known as radioactive recoil, in which a daughter nucleus is forcefully ejected as it recoils at the moment of decay.
While Hahn was more concerned with discovering new elements (now known to be isotopes), Meitner was more interested in understanding their radiation. She observed that radioactive recoil, which had been discovered by Harriet Brooks in , could be a new way of detecting radioactive substances. They soon discovered two more new isotopes, bismuth and thallium[31][32] Meitner was particularly interested in beta particles.
By this time, they were known to be electrons. Alpha particles were emitted with characteristic energy, and she expected that this would be true of beta particles too. Hahn and Meitner carefully measured the absorption of beta particles by aluminium, but the results were puzzling.
Meitner lise biography template free Report this resource to TPT. Informational text. Graphic Organizers. Perfect for distance learning, Women's History Month, biography projects, and social studies and science lessons in general!In , James Chadwick found that electrons emitted from the nucleus formed a continuous spectrum, but Meitner found this hard to believe, as it seemed to contradict quantum physics, which held that electrons in an atom can only occupy discrete energy states (quanta).
Kaiser Wilhelm Institute for Chemistry
In , Hahn and Meitner moved to the newly founded Kaiser Wilhelm Institute (KWI) for Chemistry in Berlin.
Hahn accepted an offer from Fischer to become a junior assistant in charge of its radiochemistry section, the first laboratory of its kind in Germany. The job came with the title of "professor" and a salary of 5, marks per annum (equivalent to €29, in ). Unlike the universities, the privately funded KWI had no policies excluduing women, but Meitner worked without pay as a "guest" in Hahn's section.
She may have encountered financial difficulties after the death of her father in Fearing she might return to Vienna, Planck appointed her as his assistant at the Institute for Theoretical Physics in the Friedrich Wilhelm University. As such, she marked his students' papers. It was her first paid position. Assistant was the lowest rung on the academic ladder, and Meitner was the first female scientific assistant in Prussia.
Proud officials presented Meitner to Kaiser Wilhelm II at the official opening of the KWI for Chemistry on 23 October The following year she became a Mitglied (associate) like Hahn (although her salary was still less), and the radioactivity section became the Hahn-Meitner Laboratory.
Meitner celebrated with a dinner party at the Hotel Adlon. Hahn and Meitner's salaries would soon be dwarfed by royalties from mesothorium ("middle thorium", radium, also called "German radium") produced for medical purposes, for which Hahn received 66, marks in (equivalent to €, in ). He gave ten per cent to Meitner. In , Meitner was offered an academic position in Prague, which was then part of her country of Austria-Hungary.
Planck made it clear to Fischer that he did not want Meitner to leave, and Fischer arranged for her salary to be doubled to 3, marks (equivalent to €17, in ).
The move to new accommodation was fortunate, as the wood shop had become thoroughly contaminated by radioactive liquids that had been spilt, and radioactive gases that had vented and decayed then settled as radioactive dust, making sensitive measurements impossible.
To ensure that their clean new laboratories stayed that way, Hahn and Meitner instituted strict procedures. Chemical and physical measurements were conducted in different rooms, people handling radioactive substances had to follow protocols that included not shaking hands, and rolls of toilet paper were hung next to every telephone and door handle.
Strongly radioactive substances were stored in the old wood shop, and later in a purpose-built radium house on the institute grounds.
World War I and the discovery of protactinium
In July —shortly before the outbreak of World War I—Hahn was called to active duty with the army in a Landwehr regiment.
Meitner undertook X-ray technician training, and a course on anatomy at the city hospital in Lichterfelde. Meanwhile, she completed both the work on the beta ray spectrum that she had begun before the war with Hahn and Baeyer, and her own study of the uranium decay chain. In July , she returned to Vienna, where she joined the Austrian Army as an X-ray nurse-technician.
Her unit was deployed to the Eastern front in Poland, and she also served on the Italian front before being discharged in September
Meitner returned to the KWI for Chemistry and her research in October. In January , she was appointed as head of her own physics section. The Hahn-Meitner Laboratory was divided into separate Hahn and Meitner Laboratories, and her pay was increased to 4, marks (equivalent to €10, in ).[1] Hahn returned to Berlin on leave, and they discussed another loose end from their pre-war work: the search for the mother isotope of actinium (element 89).
According to the radioactive displacement law of Fajans and Soddy, this had to be an isotope of the undiscovered element 91 on the periodic table that lay between thorium (element 90) and uranium (element 92).
Biography template free Hispanic Heritage Month. In November, , she met with Hahn in Copenhagen to prepare a set of experiments. Service learning. Independent work.Kasimir Fajans and Oswald Helmuth Göhring discovered the missing element in , and named it brevium after its short half-life. However, the isotope they had found was a beta emitter, and therefore could not be the mother isotope of actinium. This had to be another isotope of the same element.
In , Hahn and Meitner had developed a new technique for separating the tantalum group from pitchblende, which they hoped would speed the isolation of the new isotope.
When Meitner resumed this work in , Hahn and most of the students, laboratory assistants and technicians had been called up to serve in the armed forces, so Meitner had to do everything herself. In February, she extracted 2 grams of silicon dioxide (SiO
2) from 21 grams of pitchblende. She set grams aside and added a tantalum pentafluoride (TaF
5) carrier to the other grams, which she dissolved in hydrogen fluoride (HF).
She then boiled it in concentrated sulfuric acid (H
2SO
4), precipitated what was believed to be element 91, and verified that it was an alpha emitter. Hahn came home on leave in April, and together they devised a series of tests to eliminate other sources of alpha particles. The only known ones with similar chemical behaviour were lead (which decays to alpha emitter polonium via bismuth) and thorium
For this more pitchblende was required.
Meitner went to Vienna, where she met with Stefan Meyer. The export of uranium from Austria was forbidden due to wartime restrictions, but Meyer was able to offer her a kilogram of uranium residue, pitchblende from which the uranium had been removed, which was actually better for her purpose. The tests showed that the alpha activity was not due to these substances.
All that now remained was to find evidence of actinium. For this yet more pitchblende was required, but this time Meyer was unable to assist, as the export was now prohibited. Meitner managed to obtain &#;g of "double residue"—pitchblende without uranium or radium—from Friedrich Oskar Giesel and began tests with 43 grams of it, but its composition was different, and at first her tests did not work.
With Giesel's help, she was able to produce a pure product that was strongly radioactive. By December she was able to isolate both the mother isotope and its actinium daughter product. She submitted their findings for publication in March [47]
Although Fajans and Göhring had been the first to discover the element, custom required that an element was represented by its longest-lived and most abundant isotope, and brevium did not seem appropriate.
Fajans agreed to Meitner naming the element "protoactinium" (subsequently shortened to protactinium), and assigning it the chemical symbol Pa. In June , Soddy and John Cranston announced that they had independently extracted a sample of the isotope, but unlike Meitner they were unable to describe its characteristics. They acknowledged Meitner's priority, and agreed to the name.
The connection to uranium remained a mystery, as neither of the two known isotopes of uranium (uranium and uranium) decayed into protactinium. It remained unsolved until uranium was discovered by Arthur Jeffrey Dempster in [48]
Beta radiation
In , Meitner accepted an invitation from Manne Siegbahn to come to Sweden and give a series of lectures on radioactivity as a visiting professor at Lund University.
She found that very little research had been done on radioactivity in Sweden, but she was eager to learn about X-ray spectroscopy, which was Siegbahn's specialty. At his laboratory, she met a Dutch doctoral candidate, Dirk Coster, who was studying X-ray spectroscopy, and his wife Miep, who was working on her doctorate in Indonesian language and culture.
Armed with her newly acquired knowledge of X-ray spectroscopy, Meitner took a fresh look at the beta-ray spectra when she returned to Berlin. It was known that some beta emission was primary, with electrons being ejected directly from the nucleus, and some was secondary, in which alpha particles from the nucleus knocked electrons out of orbit.
Meitner lise biography template pdf Immersive learning for 25 languages. European history. This activity can easily serve as a note-taking template for an essay or presentation. PreK ELA.Meitner was sceptical of Chadwick's claim that the spectral lines were entirely due to secondary electrons, while the primary ones formed a continuous spectrum. Using techniques developed by Jean Danysz, she examined the spectra of lead, radium and thorium Meitner discovered the cause of the emission of electrons from surfaces of atoms with "signature" energies, now known as the Auger-Meitner effect, in [53] The effect is co-named for Pierre Victor Auger, who independently discovered it in [54][55]
Women were granted the right of habilitation in Prussia in , and in Meitner was granted her habilitation and became a Privatdozentin.
She was the first woman to receive her habilitation in physics in Prussia, and only the second in Germany after Hedwig Kohn. Since Meitner had already published over 40 papers, she was not required to submit a thesis, but Max von Laue recommended that the requirement for an inaugural lecture not be waived, since he was interested in what she had to say.
She therefore gave an inaugural lecture on "Problems of Cosmic Physics". From to , she taught a colloquium or tutorial at Friedrich Wilhelm University each semester, and supervised doctoral students at the KWI for Chemistry.
In , she became an außerordentlicher Professor (extraordinary professor), the first woman university physics professor in Germany. Her physics section became larger, and she acquired a permanent assistant. Scientists from Germany and around the world came to the KWI for Chemistry to conduct research under her supervision. In , Meitner taught a seminar on "Questions of Atomic Physics and Atomic Chemistry" with Leó Szilárd.
Meitner had a Wilson cloud chamber constructed at the KWI for Chemistry, the first one in Berlin, and with her student Kurt Freitag studied the tracks of alpha particles that did not collide with a nucleus.
With her assistant Kurt Philipp she later used it to take the first images of positron traces from gamma radiation. She proved Chadwick's assertion that the discrete spectral lines were entirely the result of secondary electrons, and the continuous spectra were therefore indeed entirely caused by the primary ones. In , Charles Drummond Ellis and William Alfred Wooster measured the energy of the continuous spectrum produced by the beta decay of bismuth at &#;MeV where the energy of each disintegration was &#;MeV.
Thus, the spectrum accounted for nearly, but not all, of the energy. Meitner found this result so troubling that she repeated the experiment with Wilhelm Orthmann using an improved method, and verified Ellis and Wooster's results.[59][60]
It appeared that the law of conservation of energy did not hold for beta decay, something Meitner regarded as unacceptable.
In , Wolfgang Pauli wrote an open letter to Meitner and Hans Geiger in which he proposed that the continuous spectrum was caused by the emission of a second particle during beta decay, one that had no electric charge and little or no rest mass. The idea was taken up by Enrico Fermi in his theory of beta decay, and he gave the name "neutrino" to the hypothetical neutral particle.
At the time there was scant hope of detecting neutrinos, but in Clyde Cowan and Frederick Reines did just that.
Nazi Germany
Adolf Hitler was sworn in as the Chancellor of Germany on 30 January , as his Nazi Party (NSDAP) was now the largest party in the Reichstag. The 7 April Law for the Restoration of the Professional Civil Service removed Jews from the civil service, which included academia.
Meitner never tried to conceal her Jewish descent, but initially was exempt from its impact on multiple grounds: she had been employed before , had served in the military during the World War, was an Austrian rather than a German citizen, and the Kaiser Wilhelm Institute was a government-industry partnership. However, she was dismissed from her adjunct professorship on 6 September on the grounds that her World War I service was not at the front, and she had not completed her habilitation until This had no effect on her salary or work at the KWI for Bosch, the director of IG Farben, a major sponsor of the KWI for Chemistry, assured Meitner that her position there was safe.
Although Hahn and Meitner remained in charge, their assistants, Otto Erbacher and Kurt Philipp respectively, who were both NSDAP members, were given increasing influence over the day-to-day running of the institute.
Others were not so fortunate; her nephew Otto Robert Frisch was dismissed from his post in the Institute for Physical Chemistry at the University of Hamburg, as was Otto Stern, the director of the institute.
Stern found Frisch a position with Patrick Blackett at Birkbeck College in England, and he later worked at the Niels Bohr Institute in Copenhagen from to Fritz Strassman had come to the Kaiser Wilhelm Institute for Chemistry to study under Hahn to improve his employment prospects. He declined a lucrative offer of employment because it required political training and Nazi Party membership, and resigned from the Society of German Chemists when it became part of the Nazi German Labour Front rather than become a member of a Nazi-controlled organisation.
As a result, he could neither work in the chemical industry nor receive his habilitation. Meitner persuaded Hahn to hire him as an assistant. Soon he would be credited as a third collaborator on the papers they produced, and would sometimes even be listed first. Between and , Meitner published exclusively in the journal Naturwissenschaften, as its editor Arnold Berliner was Jewish, and he continued to accept submissions from Jewish scientists.
This generated a boycott of the publication, and in August the publisher, Springer-Verlag, fired Berliner.
Transmutation
After Chadwick discovered the neutron in ,Irène Curie and Frédéric Joliot irradiated aluminium foil with alpha particles, and found that this results in a short-lived radioactive isotope of phosphorus. They noted that positron emission continued after the irradiation ceased.
Not only had they discovered a new form of radioactive decay, they had transmuted an element into a hitherto unknown radioactive isotope of another, thereby inducing radioactivity where there had been none before. Radiochemistry was now no longer confined to certain heavy elements, but extended to the entire periodic table.
Chadwick noted that being electrically neutral, neutrons could penetrate the nucleus more easily than protons or alpha particles. Enrico Fermi and his colleagues in Rome picked up on this idea, and began irradiating elements with neutrons.
The radioactive displacement law of Fajans and Soddy said that beta decay causes isotopes to move one element up on the periodic table, and alpha decay causes them to move two down.
When Fermi's group bombarded uranium atoms with neutrons, they found a complex mix of half lives. Fermi therefore concluded that new elements with atomic numbers greater than 92 (known as transuranium elements) had been created. Meitner and Hahn had not collaborated for many years, but Meitner was eager to investigate Fermi's results. Hahn, initially, was not, but he changed his mind when Aristid von Grosse suggested that what Fermi had found was an isotope of protactinium.
"The only question", Hahn later wrote, "seemed to be whether Fermi had found isotopes of transuranium elements, or isotopes of the next-lower element, protactinium. At that time Lise Meitner and I decided to repeat Fermi's experiments in order to find out whether the minute isotope was a protactinium isotope or not.
It was a logical decision, having been the discoverers of protactinium."
Between and , Hahn, Meitner, and Strassmann found a great number of radioactive transmutation products, all of which they regarded as transuranic. At that time, the existence of actinides was not yet established, and uranium was wrongly believed to be a group 6 element similar to tungsten.
It followed that the first transuranic elements would be similar to group 7 to 10 elements, rhenium and platinoids. They established the presence of multiple isotopes of at least four such elements, and (mistakenly) identified them as elements with atomic numbers 93 to They were the first scientists to measure the minute half life of the synthetic radioisotope uranium and to establish chemically that it was an isotope of uranium, but with their weak neutron sources they were unable to continue this work to its logical conclusion and identify the real element They identified ten different half lives, with varying degrees of certainty.
To account for them, Meitner had to hypothesise a new class of reaction and the alpha decay of uranium, neither of which had ever been reported before, and for which physical evidence was lacking. Hahn and Strassmann refined their chemical procedures, while Meitner devised new experiments to examine the reaction processes.
In May , Hahn and Meitner issued parallel reports, one in Zeitschrift für Physik with Meitner as the first author, and one in Chemische Berichte with Hahn as the first author.[80][81] Hahn concluded his by stating emphatically: Vor allem steht ihre chemische Verschiedenheit von allen bisher bekannten Elementen außerhalb jeder Diskussion ("Above all, their chemical distinction from all previously known elements needs no further discussion").[81] Meitner was increasingly uncertain.
She considered the possibility that the reactions were from different isotopes of uranium; three were known: uranium, uranium and uranium However, when she calculated the neutron cross section, it was too large to be anything other than the most abundant isotope, uranium, and concluded that it must be another case of nuclear isomerism, a phenomenon Hahn had discovered in protactinium years before.
She therefore ended her report on a very different note to Hahn, reporting that: "The process must be neutron capture by uranium, which leads to three isomeric nuclei of uranium This result is very difficult to reconcile with current concepts of the nucleus."[80]
Escape from Germany
With the Anschluss, Germany's annexation of Austria on 12 March , Meitner lost her Austrian Bohr extended an offer to lecture in Copenhagen, and Paul Scherrer invited her to attend a congress in Switzerland, with all expenses paid.
Carl Bosch still said that she could remain at the KWI for Chemistry, but by May she was aware that the Reich Ministry of Science, Education and Culture was looking into her case. On 9 May, she decided to accept Bohr's invitation to go to Copenhagen, where Frisch worked, but when she went to the Danish consulate to get a travel visa, she was told that Denmark no longer recognised her Austrian passport as valid.
She could not leave for Denmark, Switzerland or any other country.
Bohr came to Berlin in June, and was gravely concerned. When he returned to Copenhagen, he began looking for a position for Meitner in Scandinavia. He also asked Hans Kramers to see if anything was available in the Netherlands. Kramers contacted Coster, who in turn notified Adriaan Fokker.
Coster and Fokker attempted to secure a position for Meitner at the University of Groningen. They found that the Rockefeller Foundation would not support refugee scientists, and that the International Federation of University Women had been flooded with applications for support from Austria. On 27 June, Meitner received an offer of a one-year position at Manne Siegbahn's new Manne Siegbahn Laboratory&#;[sv] in Stockholm, then under construction, which would be devoted to nuclear physics, and she decided to accept it.
But on 4 July she learned that academics would no longer be granted permission to travel abroad.
Through Bohr in Copenhagen, Peter Debye communicated with Coster and Fokker, and they approached the Netherlands Ministry of Education with an appeal to allow Meitner to come to the Netherlands. As foreigners were not allowed to work for pay, an appointment as a non-salaried privaat-docente was required.
Wander Johannes de Haas and Anton Eduard van Arkel arranged for one at Leiden University. Coster also spoke to the head of the border guards, who assured him that Meitner would be admitted. A friend of Coster, E. H. Ebels, was a local politician from the border area, and he spoke directly to the guards on the border.
On 11 July, Coster arrived in Berlin, where he stayed with Debye.
The following morning, Meitner arrived early at the KWI for Chemistry, and Hahn briefed her on the plan. To avoid suspicion, she maintained her usual routine, remaining at the institute until correcting one of the associate's papers for publication. Hahn and Paul Rosbaud helped her pack two small suitcases, carrying only summer clothes. Hahn gave her a diamond ring he had inherited from his mother in case of emergency; she took only 10 marks in her purse (equivalent to €40 in ).
She then spent the night at Hahn's house. The next morning Meitner met Coster at the railway station, where they pretended to have met by chance. They travelled on a lightly used line to Bad Nieuweschans railway station on the border, which they crossed without incident; the German border guards may have thought that Meitner was the wife of a professor.
A telegram from Pauli informed Coster that he was now "as famous for the abduction of Lise Meitner as for the discovery of hafnium".
Meitner learned on 26 July that Sweden had granted her permission to enter on her Austrian passport, and two days later she flew to Copenhagen, where she was greeted by Frisch, and stayed with Niels and Margrethe Bohr at their holiday house in Tisvilde.
On 1 August she travelled by train and steamship to Göteborg station in Sweden, where she was met at by Eva von Bahr. They took a train, and then a steamer, to von Bahr's home in Kungälv, where she stayed until September. Hahn told everyone at the KWI for Chemistry that Meitner had gone to Vienna to visit her relatives, and a few days later the institute had closed for the summer.
Meitner lise biography template Graphic organizers. Comprehensive K personalized learning. Word problems. Get newsletter.On 23 August, she wrote to Bosch requesting retirement. He tried to ship her belongings to Sweden, but the Reich Ministry of Education insisted they remain in Germany.
Meitner was also concerned about her family in Austria. One of her first actions in Sweden was to apply for a Swedish immigration permit for Gusti and her husband Justinian (Jutz) Frisch.
Hahn selected Josef Mattauch to replace her as head of the physics section, and went to Vienna to offer him the job. While there he dined with Meitner's sisters Gusti and Gisela and their husbands Jutz Frisch and Karl Lion on 9 November. The next day Gusti informed him that Frisch had been arrested. That day, Meitner arrived in Copenhagen; arranging a travel visa had been difficult with her invalid Austrian passport.
Hahn joined her in Copenhagen on 13 November, and had discussions about the uranium research with Meitner, Bohr and Otto Robert Frisch.
Nuclear fission
Main article: Discovery of nuclear fission
Hahn and Strassmann isolated the three radium isotopes (verified by their half-lives) and used fractional crystallisation to separate it from its barium carrier by adding barium bromide crystals in four steps.
Since radium precipitates preferentially in a solution of barium bromide, at each step the fraction drawn off would contain less radium than the one before. However, they found no difference between each of the fractions. In case their process was faulty in some way, they verified it with known isotopes of radium; the process was fine.
On 19 December, Hahn wrote to Meitner, informing her that the radium isotopes behaved chemically like barium. Anxious to finish up before the Christmas break, Hahn and Strassmann submitted their findings to Naturwissenschaften on 22 December without waiting for Meitner to reply. Hahn concluded the paper with: "As chemists we should substitute the symbols Ba, La, Ce for Ra, Ac, Th.
As 'nuclear chemists' fairly close to physics we cannot yet bring ourselves to take this step which contradicts all previous experience in physics."[98]
Frisch normally celebrated Christmas with Meitner in Berlin, but in she accepted an invitation from Eva von Bahr to spend it with her family at Kungälv, and Meitner asked Frisch to join her there.
Meitner received the letter from Hahn describing his chemical proof that some of the product of the bombardment of uranium with neutrons was barium. Barium had an atomic mass 40% less than uranium, and no previously known methods of radioactive decay could account for such a large difference in the mass of the nucleus.
Nonetheless, she had immediately written back to Hahn to say: "At the moment the assumption of such a thoroughgoing breakup seems very difficult to me, but in nuclear physics we have experienced so many surprises, that one cannot unconditionally say: 'It is impossible.'"
Meitner dismissed the possibility that Hahn's identification of barium was in error; her faith in Hahn's expertise as a chemist was absolute.
Meitner and Frisch then considered how it could be possible. Previous attempts at atom splitting had never had enough energy to chip away more than individual protons or alpha particles, but a barium nucleus was much larger. They considered the liquid-drop model of the nucleus that had been proposed by George Gamow: perhaps it was possible for a drop to become elongated and then divide itself in two.
Frisch later wrote:
At that point we both sat down on a tree trunk (all that discussion had taken place while we walked through the wood in the snow, I with my skis on, Lise Meitner making good her claim that she could walk just as fast without), and started to calculate on scraps of paper.
The charge of a uranium nucleus, we found, was indeed large enough to overcome the effect of the surface tension almost completely; so the uranium nucleus might indeed resemble a very wobbly unstable drop, ready to divide itself at the slightest provocation, such as the impact of a single neutron.
But there was another problem.
After separation, the two drops would be driven apart by their mutual electric repulsion and would acquire high speed and hence a very large energy, about &#;MeV in all; where could that energy come from? Fortunately Lise Meitner remembered the empirical formula for computing the masses of nuclei and worked out that the two nuclei formed by the division of a uranium nucleus together would be lighter than the original uranium nucleus by about one-fifth the mass of a proton.
Now whenever mass disappears energy is created, according to Einstein's formula E&#;= mc2, and one-fifth of a proton mass was just equivalent to &#;MeV. So here was the source for that energy; it all fitted!
Meitner and Frisch had correctly interpreted Hahn's results to mean that the nucleus of uranium had split roughly in half.
The first two reactions that the Berlin group had observed were light elements created by the breakup of uranium nuclei; the third, the minute one, was a decay into the real element On returning to Copenhagen, Frisch informed Bohr, who slapped his forehead and exclaimed "What idiots we have been!" Bohr promised not to say anything until they had a paper ready for publication.
To speed the process, they decided to submit a one-page note to Nature. At this point, the only evidence that they had was the barium. Logically, if barium was formed, the other element must be krypton, but Hahn had mistakenly believed that the atomic masses had to add up to rather than the atomic numbers adding up to 92, and thought it was masurium (technetium), and so did not check for it:
92U + n →
56Ba +
36Kr + some n [b]
Over a series of long-distance phone calls, Meitner and Frisch came up with a simple experiment to bolster their claim: to measure the recoil of the fission fragments, using a Geiger counter with the threshold set above that of the alpha particles.
Frisch conducted the experiment on 13 January, and found the pulses caused by the reaction just as they had predicted. He decided he needed a name for the newly discovered nuclear process. He spoke to William A. Arnold, an American biologist working with George de Hevesy, and asked him what biologists called the process by which living cells divided into two.
Arnold told him that biologists called it fission. Frisch then applied that name to the nuclear process in his paper. He mailed both papers to Nature on 16 January; the jointly-authored note appeared in print on 11 February and Frisch's paper on recoil on 18 February.[][]
These three reports, the first Hahn-Strassmann publications of 6 January and 10 February , and the Frisch-Meitner publication of 11 February , had electrifying effects on the scientific community.
In Frisch and Rudolf Peierls produced the Frisch–Peierls memorandum, which established that an atomic explosion could be generated.
Nobel Prize
Despite the many honours that Meitner received in her lifetime, she did not receive the Nobel Prize while it was awarded to Otto Hahn for the discovery of nuclear fission. She was nominated 49 times for Physics and Chemistry Nobel Prizes but never won.[] On 15 November , the Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences announced that Hahn had been awarded the Nobel Prize in Chemistry for "his discovery of the fission of heavy atomic nuclei".[][c] Meitner was the one who told Hahn and Strassman to test their radium in more detail, and it was she who told Hahn that it was possible for the nucleus of uranium to disintegrate.
Without these contributions of Meitner, Hahn would not have found that the uranium nucleus can split in half.
In the Nobel Committee for Chemistry in Sweden that selected the Nobel Prize in Chemistry decided to award that prize solely to Hahn, who found out from a newspaper while detained in Farm Hall in England.
In the s, the long-sealed records of the Nobel Committee's proceedings became public, and the comprehensive biography of Meitner published in by Ruth Lewin Sime took advantage of this unsealing to reconsider Meitner's exclusion.
In a article in the American Physical Society journal Physics Today, Sime and her colleagues Elisabeth Crawford and Mark Walker wrote:
It appears that Lise Meitner did not share the prize because the structure of the Nobel committees was ill-suited to assess interdisciplinary work; because the members of the chemistry committee were unable or unwilling to judge her contribution fairly; and because during the war the Swedish scientists relied on their own limited expertise.
Meitner's exclusion from the chemistry award may well be summarized as a mixture of disciplinary bias, political obtuseness, ignorance, and haste.
Max Perutz, the Nobel Prize for chemistry winner reached a similar conclusion:
Having been locked up in the Nobel Committee's files these fifty years, the documents leading to this unjust award now reveal that the protracted deliberations by the Nobel jury were hampered by lack of appreciation both of the joint work that had preceded the discovery and of Meitner's written and verbal contributions after her flight from Berlin.[]
The five-member physics committee included Manne Siegbahn; his former student Erik Hulthén, the professor of experimental physics at Uppsala University; and Axel Lindh, who eventually succeeded Hulthén.
All three were part of the Siegbahn school of X-ray spectroscopy. The poor relationship between Siegbahn and Meitner was a factor here, as was the bias towards experimental rather than theoretical physics.[] In his report on the work of Meitner and Frisch, Hulthén relied on pre-war papers. He did not think that their work was groundbreaking and argued that the prize for physics was given for experimental rather than theoretical work, which had not been the case for many years.
At the time Meitner herself wrote in a letter: "Surely Hahn fully deserved the Nobel Prize for chemistry. There is really no doubt about it. But I believe that Frisch and I contributed something not insignificant to the clarification of the process of uranium fission—how it originates and that it produces so much energy and that was something very remote to Hahn." Hahn's Nobel Prize was long expected; both he and Meitner had been nominated for both the chemistry and the physics prizes several times even before the discovery of nuclear fission.
According to the Nobel Prize archive, she was nominated 19 times for Nobel Prize in Chemistry between and , and 30 times for Nobel Prize in Physics between and Her nominators included Arthur Compton, Dirk Coster, Kasimir Fajans, James Franck, Otto Hahn, Oscar Klein, Niels Bohr, Max Planck and Max Born.[][] Despite not having been awarded the Nobel Prize, Meitner was invited to attend the Lindau Nobel Laureate Meeting in []
Later life
Meitner found that Siegbahn did not want her.
At the time the offer to come to Sweden had been extended, he had said that he had no money, and could only offer Meitner a place to work. Eva von Bahr had then written to Carl Wilhelm Oseen